My first question was
Was the effect of Gandhiji's QUIT INDIA movement MINIMAL for Bharat to get independence?
The result from the Google Bard is as follows
Whether the effect of Gandhiji's Quit India Movement was minimal for Bharat to get independence is a matter of debate among historians. Some argue that the movement was a failure because it was crushed by the British and did not achieve its immediate goal of forcing the British to leave India. Others argue that the movement had a significant impact on the British decision to grant India independence, even if it was not immediately successful.
One of the main arguments in favor of the view that the Quit India Movement had a minimal impact on India's independence is that the British were already planning to leave India by the time the movement took place. The Second World War had been a major drain on British resources, and the British government was facing increasing pressure from the United States to grant India independence. The Quit India Movement may have accelerated the British decision to leave India, but it is unlikely that it was the sole factor that led to independence.
Another argument in favor of the view that the Quit India Movement had a minimal impact is that the movement was poorly organized and did not have widespread support. The British were able to suppress the movement relatively easily, and the Indian National Congress leadership was imprisoned for most of the war.
However, there are also a number of arguments in favor of the view that the Quit India Movement had a significant impact on India's independence. One argument is that the movement showed the British that Indian nationalism was a powerful force that could not be ignored. The Quit India Movement was the largest and most widespread anti-colonial movement in Indian history, and it demonstrated to the British that the Indian people were united in their demand for independence.
Another argument in favor of the view that the Quit India Movement had a significant impact is that it helped to mobilize the Indian people and to spread the message of nationalism. The movement inspired millions of Indians to take action against British rule, and it helped to create a sense of national unity.
Finally, some historians argue that the Quit India Movement had a significant impact on the British government's decision to grant India independence. The British government was concerned about the possibility of a more violent uprising in India, and it was also worried about the potential impact of the Quit India Movement on its relations with the United States. These concerns may have helped to persuade the British government to grant India independence sooner rather than later.
Overall, it is difficult to say definitively whether the Quit India Movement had a minimal impact on India's independence. There are strong arguments to be made on both sides of the debate. However, it is clear that the movement was a significant event in the history of India's freedom struggle, and it helped to lay the groundwork for India's independence in 1947.
In addition to the above, it is worth noting that former British Prime Minister Clement Attlee himself reportedly said that the extent of Gandhi's influence upon the British decision to quit India was "minimal." This suggests that even some British officials believed that the Quit India Movement was not a major factor in the British decision to grant India independence.
Ultimately, it is up to each individual to decide whether or not they believe that the Quit India Movement had a minimal impact on India's independence. There is no easy answer to this question, and there are strong arguments to be made on both sides of the debate.
My second question was related with the first one.
It was
Was the QUIT INDIA or the INA soldier's trial that triggered the naval mutiny for which the British left India in a hurry
The answer given by Google Bard is
The Indian National Army (INA) trials were a major factor in triggering the Royal Indian Navy mutiny of 1946. The INA was a military force raised by Subhas Chandra Bose to fight against British rule in India during World War II. After the war, the British government tried several INA officers for treason. This sparked widespread anger and protests in India, and it also had a significant impact on the Indian Navy.
Many sailors in the Indian Navy were sympathetic to the INA and its cause. They were also unhappy with their own working conditions and the discrimination they faced from British officers. The INA trials were the final straw for many sailors, and they decided to mutiny.
The naval mutiny began on February 18, 1946, in Bombay. It quickly spread to other ports across India, and it involved over 20,000 sailors. The mutineers demanded better pay, better working conditions, and an end to discrimination. They also demanded that the British government release the INA prisoners.
The British government was caught off guard by the mutiny, and they were unable to suppress it quickly. The mutiny lasted for several days, and it caused a great deal of chaos and disruption. The British government was eventually forced to release the INA prisoners and to make some concessions to the mutineers.
The naval mutiny was a major turning point in the Indian independence movement. It showed the British that they could no longer rely on the Indian military to maintain their rule. The mutiny also accelerated the British government's decision to grant India independence.
It is difficult to say definitively whether the Quit India Movement or the INA trials were the main factors in triggering the naval mutiny. However, it is clear that both events played a role. The Quit India Movement had helped to create a climate of anti-British sentiment in India, and the INA trials had focused attention on the issue of Indian nationalism. The naval mutiny was the culmination of these factors, and it forced the British government to reconsider its position in India.
In addition to the above, it is worth noting that former British Prime Minister Clement Attlee himself reportedly said that the naval mutiny was one of the main factors that led to the British decision to grant India independence. This suggests that the British government was very concerned about the potential impact of the mutiny on its ability to maintain control of India.
Overall, it is likely that both the Quit India Movement and the INA trials played a role in triggering the naval mutiny. However, the naval mutiny itself was the key factor that forced the British government to leave India in a hurry.
